Posted by
reasonmclucus on Wednesday, September 16, 2009 6:49:26 PM
Lucas
Wondra has achieved something only about
4
% of those who enter scouting achieve. He has
achieved the rank of
Eagle Scout.
His achievement is particularly significant because the 16-year-old
Hutchinson (Kansas) High School student has the genetic disorder Down
Syndrome. Lucas is one of many who are
demonstrating that individuals with Down Syndrome can be
productive members of society. Maybe they are not
capable of performing brain surgery or becoming
professional athletes, but then neither are the vast
majority of the rest of us.
Individuals with Down Syndrome have an extra
copy of
chromosome
21 , a condition called trisomy 21, which can
cause physical and mental
disabilities because having three copies of some genes interferes with
the normal operation of cells and development. Down
Syndrome children may
not be geniuses,
but many of them are able to attend classes with other students instead
of being limited to special education classes as was once the
case.
The cause of the extra copy of the chromosome is unknown, but it is
known that an extra copy may be received from one of the parents or the
extra chromosome may appear
during the embryonic stage of development resulting in some cells with
the extra copy and some with only two copies of chromosome
21. The possibility of an extra chromosome developing in
embryonic cells is a
major reason why embryonic cells may be unsafe to use in treating human
disorders
Lucas isn't the first Scout with Down Syndrome to earn the rank of
Eagle
Scout. For
example,
Adam
Townsend of Mesquite, Texas, became an Eagle Scout on June1, 2009.
A.
J. Trueblood of Lakeland, Florida, became an Eagle Scout in
August, 2006.
Clayton
"Trey" Henderson of Ridgeview High School in Orange Park, Florida,
became an Eagle Scout in April, 2006.
Down Syndrome scouts have to meet the same
requirements as other Eagle Scouts if they are physically able to do
so. A. J. Trueblood didn't even mention that he had Down Syndrome
on his application.
Lucas is unable to swim so he substituted a 20 mile
hike. He also completed five 10 mile hikes. I don't
know if I even hiked 20 miles when I took basic training in the army,
although it sometimes felt like 20 miles.
Lucas is physically unable to speak but can
communicate using sign language and a
PDA
with voice
software. He used the PDA to communicate with a
congregation while serving as a chaplain's aide including offering a
thought for the day and leading in the Lord's Prayer.
Many of those with Down Syndrome never had the opportunity for
achievement that these Eagle Scouts had because their mothers listened
to ignorant, prejudiced doctors and others who persuaded them to
have
abortions. Many share the prejudiced (or is it bigoted)
view of
Nicholas
Provenzo that
"a person afflicted
with Down syndrome
is only capable of being marginally productive (if at all) and requires
constant care and supervision."
Provenzo obviously doesn't understand what those with Down Syndrome can
do. I
wonder how many of those who think Down Syndrome individuals cannot do
anything had the drive to become Eagle Scouts.
Perhaps the lamest argument for aborting Down Syndrome babies has been
suggested to students on more than one occasion by University of North
Carolina Chapel Hill Professor
Albert
K. Harris. "In my opinion, the moral thing for older
mothers to do is to have
amniocentesis, as soon during pregnancy as is safe for the fetus, test
whether placental cells have a third chromosome #21, and abort the
fetus if it does. The brain is the last organ to become functional."
"I know somebody who had a child like this, and it ruined
their life," he said.
Down Syndrome babies do require more time and effort than some other
babies, but that doesn't mean they should not have the opportunity to
be born and live.
Active "normal" children may actually require more supervision than
Down Syndrome children because they may be physically able to get into
dangerous situations faster than Down Syndrome children.
Potential parents who are concerned that a child with Down Syndrome
might require more of their time should reconsider the decision to
become parents. Down Syndrome isn't the worst thing that can
happen to
a child.
A child could be afflicted with a fatal form of cancer or Muscular
Dystrophy. A child might be severely injured in an accident or
abducted.
A child might require greater effort from
parents because of hyperactivity or autism. A "normal"
child may decide to get involved with drugs or gangs.
These and many other problems that can occur with children can
adversely affect families, but the problem isn't with the children.
Major illness of the death of a child from any cause potentially can
destroy a family if parents start playing a blame game. The problem in
these situations is with parents who cannot accept adversity.
Sue Thomas
was born in May, 1950, and was a normal child until she suddenly
lost
her hearing at 18 months. The
"experts" told her
parents that she would never amount to anything and should be
institutionalized. Her parents ignored the advice and made sure
that she had the opportunity for as normal a life as
possible including attending school with children who could
hear.
At the age of 7 she
became the youngest Ohio Champion free style skater
in history. In 1979, she became part of an elite FBI
surveillance team. In 2002 a tv series
Sue Thomas: F.B. Eye
debuted based on her career, although many of the episodes dealt
with the type cases facing the FBI at the time of the
series rather than cases from the 80's. The
Gospel
Music Channel is bringing that series back on September 14.
Some people try to define others by what they cannot do instead of what
they can do. Lucas Wondra, Adam Townsend, A.J. Trueblood and
Clayton Henderson have done something I couldn't have done when I was
their age. They have become Eagle Scouts.
I was a Cub Scout, but my family moved to another town when I was in
the 6th grade and I never became a Boy Scout. Even if I
had participated, I doubt that I could have fulfilled the requirements
for an Eagle Scout because I was
the stereotypical "98 pound weakling" in high school.
I cannot play a musical instrument like
Sarah Itoh
who has Down Syndrome and who was playing the clarinet by the time she
was11 years old. She is an
accomplished public speaker who particularly enjoys telling audiences
how she enjoys Special Olympics. At her age I had enough
trouble just repeating lines in a church Christmas play.
We all have different abilities and disabilities. We can do
some things that others cannot do and they can do some things that we
cannot do.
Sue Thomas responded to her loss of hearing by learning to read
lips. That skill got her a job as an FBI
agent because she could what other FBI agents could not do.
She
could tell what a suspect under visual surveillance was
saying without the need to plant a microphone near him.
We don't know the full potential of what individuals with Down
Syndrome can do because for many years people just labeled them
"retarded" and assumed they couldn't do anything. Maybe none of
the Eagle Scouts mentioned will become an astronaut like Eagle
Scout
Neil
Armstrong or a movie director like Eagle Scout
Steven Spielberg.
However, drama student and cheerleader Clayton Henderson might
become a successful actor like
Joseph
"Chris" Burke who has Down Syndrome and was a
star of the successful tv series "
Life
Goes On.."
How many of us could star in a tv series?
Some people claim that Down Syndrome children cost society because of
government programs that have assisted them. I doubt seriously
all Down Syndrome individuals together have cost society nearly
as much as Bernie Madoff.